🚐 ALP Vans · We Come To You · Fully Mobile · Nationwide UK
← Back to Guides & Tools
Expert Comparison

Lithium vs Lead Acid Batteries: Which is Best?

Complete comparison of lithium and lead-acid batteries for campervans - capacity, weight, lifespan, and cost analysis

By Volt Vans Team14 min readUpdated November 2024

Choosing between lithium (LiFePO4) and lead-acid batteriesis one of the biggest decisions in your campervan electrical system. Lead-acid costs less upfront, but lithium delivers 2x the usable power at half the weight and lasts 10x longer.

After installing hundreds of both types, we're now lithium-only for new builds. This guide breaks down every aspect so you can make an informed decision for your budget and usage.

Quick Answer

For 95% of campervans, lithium is the better choice. Yes, it costs 3-4x more initially, but you get double the usable capacity, half the weight, and it lasts 10x longer. Over the battery's lifetime, lithium is significantly cheaper per Wh delivered.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Usable Capacity

Lithium Wins

Lithium (LiFePO4)

100% usable capacity

100Ah battery = 1200Wh usable power

Lead-Acid / AGM

50% usable capacity

100Ah battery = 600Wh usable power

Why it matters: Lead-acid batteries suffer severe voltage drop below 50% charge. Lithium delivers full capacity without voltage sag.

Weight

Lithium Wins

Lithium (LiFePO4)

13-15kg for 100Ah

50-70% lighter than lead-acid

Lead-Acid / AGM

30-35kg for 100Ah

Heavy and difficult to move

Why it matters: Lithium's light weight improves fuel economy, payload capacity, and makes installation much easier.

Lifespan

Lithium Wins

Lithium (LiFePO4)

3000-5000 cycles

10-15 years typical lifespan

Lead-Acid / AGM

300-500 cycles

2-4 years typical lifespan

Why it matters: Lithium batteries last 10x longer. Over time, they're significantly cheaper per Wh delivered.

Charge Speed

Lithium Wins

Lithium (LiFePO4)

1C rate (100Ah in 1 hour)

Accepts high charge current

Lead-Acid / AGM

0.2C rate (100Ah in 5 hours)

Slow charging required

Why it matters: Lithium charges 5x faster, crucial for short solar windows and drive time charging.

Maintenance

Lithium Wins

Lithium (LiFePO4)

Zero maintenance

Sealed, no water topping up

Lead-Acid / AGM

Regular maintenance

Check water levels, clean terminals

Why it matters: Lithium is completely maintenance-free. Lead-acid requires regular checks and terminal cleaning.

Temperature Performance

Lithium Wins

Lithium (LiFePO4)

Excellent -20°C to 50°C

Minimal capacity loss in cold

Lead-Acid / AGM

Poor below 0°C

Loses 50% capacity in winter

Why it matters: Lithium performs well in cold weather. Lead-acid loses significant capacity when it gets cold.

Initial Cost

Lead-Acid Wins

Lithium (LiFePO4)

£400-600 for 100Ah

Higher upfront investment

Lead-Acid / AGM

£100-200 for 100Ah

Cheaper to buy initially

Why it matters: Lead-acid wins on initial cost, but you'll replace it 5-10x more often than lithium.

The Real Cost Over Time

Everyone focuses on the initial price, but that's misleading. Here's what you'll actually spend over 10 years:

Lithium (LiFePO4)

Initial purchase (200Ah):£900
Replacements in 10 years:£0
Maintenance costs:£0
Total 10-year cost:£900

Usable energy: 2400Wh × 3000 cycles = 7,200,000Wh

Cost per kWh delivered: £0.125

Lead-Acid (AGM)

Initial purchase (400Ah needed):£400
Replacements (every 3 years):£1,200
Maintenance & terminals:£100
Total 10-year cost:£1,700

Usable energy: 2400Wh × 500 cycles = 1,200,000Wh

Cost per kWh delivered: £1.42

The Math is Clear

Lithium costs £900 upfront but £0.125 per kWh delivered.

Lead-acid costs £400 upfront but £1.42 per kWh delivered - over 11x more expensive per unit of energy when you factor in replacements and reduced capacity.

Lithium battery installation in campervan

When Lead-Acid Might Make Sense

We're not saying lead-acid is always wrong. There are specific scenarios where it might be appropriate:

✓ Very Limited Budget

If you literally cannot afford £400-600 upfront for lithium, a £150 lead-acid AGM will get you going. Just understand you'll need to replace it in 2-3 years and it only gives 50% usable capacity.

✓ Rarely Used Van

If you only use the van 5-10 nights per year, a lead-acid battery might outlast your ownership. The lifespan advantage of lithium doesn't matter if you're not cycling it frequently.

✓ Selling Van Soon

Planning to sell within 1-2 years? Lead-acid gets you through that period cheaply, and the next owner might not value the lithium upgrade enough to justify your investment.

Our recommendation: If you're building a proper campervan conversion that you'll use regularly, save up the extra £500 for lithium. It's worth it. If money is genuinely tight, get a single 100Ah lithium battery rather than 2x 100Ah lead-acid - you'll get the same usable power and can add more lithium later.

Charging System Requirements

Lithium Charging

  • Requires DC-DC charger (not split charge relay)
  • Charge voltage: 14.4V bulk, 13.5V float
  • No equalization stage needed
  • Solar MPPT with lithium profile
  • Don't charge below 0°C without heater

Modern equipment has lithium profiles built-in

Lead-Acid Charging

  • Can use old split charge relay (not recommended)
  • Charge voltage: 14.4-14.8V bulk, 13.6V float
  • Monthly equalization charge at 15.5V
  • Any solar controller works
  • Slow charge rates (max 0.2C)

Requires more complex charging profile

Important: If you switch from lead-acid to lithium, you MUST update your DC-DC charger and solar controller settings to lithium profiles. Using lead-acid charging voltages will damage lithium batteries.

Expert Battery Installation

We'll help you choose between lithium and lead-acid based on your budget, usage, and plans. Our installations include correctly sized cables, appropriate fusing, proper charge settings, and battery monitoring. We work with premium brands like Fogstar, Victron, and Renogy for lithium, or quality AGM if lead-acid is your choice.

Get in touch for a free consultation →

Ready to Choose Your Battery?

Get expert advice on the right battery for your campervan